Sometimes every portfolio needs to take on a speculative or
more risky position in order to reap huge rewards, which brings me to 2 crazy
trades that may be just too crazy to pass up. Both of these stocks are going in
complete opposite directions, but that could change very quickly. So, if you’re
looking for a way to spark your portfolio, consider buying Michael Kors (KORS)
and/or selling Shake Shack (SHAK).
On Wednesday morning, Michael Kors reported another
horrendous quarter with awful guidance, reporting earnings growth of 15% to $0.90/share
vs. already reduced estimates of $0.91/share. At the same time, the company
missed on weak revenues estimates, reporting growth of 18% to $1.04B vs.
$1.08B. It got even worse for Michael Kors when they reported same-store sales
actually DECREASED 6.7%, well below expectations. After I saw that sales number
I had to look twice thinking it was an error, but nevertheless, it was no
error. Management used every possible excuse they could to blame for the weak
sales, saying the miss was caused by a stronger US Dollar and lower tourist
traffic, bad winter weather, shutdowns at the ports, etc… Unfortunately for
Kors, these are the same excuses that all of their competitors and every other
company in world used as their excuse for missing sales, however almost none of
them missed as badly as Kors, which leads me to believe that there is something
bigger going on here. Another reason to believe that the problems they had last
quarter are not behind them is because of the weak FY16 guidance they gave, expecting
$4.75B in revenues and $4.45/share in earnings. Those numbers were also well
below analyst estimates of $4.70 in EPS and $5.05B in revenues. I also didn’t
even mention that operating expenses are rising and due to steep discounts
because of excess inventory and weak sales, margins compressed more than
expected as well.
So why on earth do I think Michael Kors can rally? I think
things at Kors have gotten so hideously bad, that they just can’t get any
worse. Fashion trends are always changing and with some changes of their own,
Kors could once again dominate the high-end market. This used to be a stock
that traded at 50x forward earnings, however with the stock selling of 25% on
Wednesday, Kors trades at just 11x FY16 earnings, which is very cheap
considering they just reported FY15 EPS and revenue growth in excess of 30%
each. Additionally, on a constant currency basis, same-store sales increased
almost 12% YoY, with the company seeing big growth in their e-commerce
business. While their US business is slowing down (revenues were still up 20%),
their international business has seen huge growth with revenue out of Europe
and Japan up 70%. Their e-commerce business is where the company can really
gain steam. Management has said that will be the focus going forward,
committing to in-store mobile and social media presence and introducing Kors
concierge, where store associates will have mobile devices to personalize the
shopping experience and increase customer engagement. Kors has done a nice job
building their balance sheet, increasing their cash position to almost $1B with
no debt. They are buying back stock and just authorized an additional $500M
buyback through 2017.
On a technical perspective, the stock has dropped so much
that you have to look at it from a lifetime perspective, which for Kors,
started in 2012. The 23.6% Fibonacci retracement is $41.81, which is a level
the stock hasn’t closed below since August 2012. With Kors closing on Friday at
$46.50, I would wait until it gets closer to $44 to pull the trigger if you're trading it and use
$41.81 as your risk tolerance, so don’t take it much lower than that. For an investment, just buy on Monday and look for a rally back up to $57, giving you about 22% upside.
At the opposite end of the spectrum is Shake Shack. Much
like a lot of the IPOs in the last year, Shake Shack is trading at an insane
valuation shortly after going public. On January 30, Shack opened for trading
at $47 and is up 76%, after being up 106% on Monday, trading to an all-time
high of $96.75. Both Mobileye, GoPro, and El Pollo Loco acted the same way when
they went public, rallying more than 100%, only to crater soon thereafter. The
good new for Shack is that despite its strong earnings growth, its only trading
at 552x FY15 earnings with a price-to-earnings growth rate of 20. To give you
perspective, Jack in the Box has a market cap of $3.25B comparable to Shack,
trading at just 24x next year’s earnings and PEG ratio of 1.73. Even Chipotle,
a restaurant stock, often seen as expensive, is only trading at 30x FY15
earnings, with a PEG ratio of 1.7. Each Shack restaurant is worth about $40M,
while each Starbucks is valued at just $2.5M. Shake Shack’s management recently
announced new expansion plans, however also capped the number of US locations
they plan to open at 450. Did I forget to mention that with the company’s
current $3B market cap, ] they reported Q1 revenues of only $38M and sales
growth of 11.7%? Last quarter, Jack in the Box (again, same market cap as
Shack) reported revenues of 10x as much.
There is already an incredible short interest in Shake Shack
with about 40% of the shares held short, so any rally in the stock is only caused
by a short squeeze and has absolutely nothing to do with fundamentals. But with
that said, this stock can really move sharply higher for no reason, as it’s
done all year long and did on Friday. Another reason the stock is so wildly
traded is because options have yet to price due to the only 12M shares
outstanding. At the end of July, Shack will have a lock-up expiration that will
almost certainly lead to significant selling pressure, as you saw with Go Pro,
Alibaba, Mobileye and all of the others. There is no question that Shake Shack
is a very well run company, with a cult following, great food and long-term
expansion plans (with new locations and the recent rumors about the company
adding chicken to their menus or opening restaurants named Chicken Shack).
However, at the ridiculous valuation that Shack currently trades at, more money
can be made selling the stock rather than buying it.
Shack rallied 9% on Monday for again, absolutely no reason
at all, so I recommend waiting until the stock moves back closer to $100 to
sell it short. Based on Fibonacci analysis, I don’t see Shack rallying much
higher than $105 and if you love shorting it at $100, you’ll love shorting it
even more at $105. So if you’re ready for this trade, put half of your position
on between $95-$100 and sell the other half if it hits $105.
My current positions: Long
Gilead Sciences (GILD), Starbucks (SBUX), Facebook (FB), Wells Fargo (WFC),
ConocoPhillips (COP), Time Warner (TWX), Twitter (TWTR), NXP Semiconductors
(NXPI), Lockheed Martin (LMT), Darden Restaurants (DRI), Celgene (CELG),
Mobileye (MBLY), Jack In The Box (JACK), Under Armour (UA), United Rentals
(URI), Regeneron (REGN), Restoration Hardware (RH), Apple (AAPL), Southwest
Airlines (LUV), Dow Chemical (DOW), L Brands (LB), Dr. Pepper Snapple (DPS),
Costco (COST) and long UnitedHealth Group (UNH) JUNE CALLS, Mobileye (MBLY) JUNE
CALLS, and Apple (AAPL) JUNE CALLS.
Jeff Lewison